Asphalt shingle roofs and metal roofs compared by cost drivers, life, weight, noise, hail, wind and appearance.
Asphalt shingles are the standard roof for many reasons. They come in many colors, install quickly, can be repaired shingle by shingle and cost less up front than most alternatives. Metal roofs cost more to install, but they can last longer, shed water and snow easily, resist fire and handle high winds well when installed correctly. Metal comes in standing seam, ribbed panels and shingle-like profiles.
Which one fits depends on your priorities. Shingles suit tight budgets, complex roof shapes and owners who want a traditional look. Metal suits owners who want longevity, a modern or farmhouse style or a roof that sheds debris. Hail can dent thin metal, while shingles can bruise and lose granules. We explain these details honestly and help Nashville owners weigh up cost, life and style.
Shingles usually cost less to install than metal.
Metal often lasts longer, with proper installation.
Both can perform well. Product and installation decide.
Solid decking and underlayment reduce noise on both.
Shingles are traditional. Metal can be modern or rustic.
Shingles repair easily. Metal panels need matching parts.
Asphalt Shingle RoofingClassic asphalt shingle roofs installed over clean decking, proper underlayment and sound flashing, with colors and styles for…Explore 
Stone-Coated Steel RoofingSteel panels coated with stone granules and shaped like tile, shake or shingle for a traditional look with…Explore 
TPO and PVC RoofingHeat-welded single-ply membranes in white and light colors for flat and low-slope roofs on homes and commercial buildings.Explore Size a roof, check its age or ballpark a budget.
Roofing, Siding and Gutter Size CalculatorEnter your measurements to see roof squares and shingle bundles, siding area and gutter lengths to plan for.Try it 
Roof Age and Replacement Timing CheckerPick your roof material, age and warning signs to see a general replacement outlook and what to do next.Try it 
Roof Replacement Budget PlannerPick a roofing, siding or gutter project, set the size and add extras to see a ballpark planning range. Placeholder values only.Try it Many owners value its life and look. We compare numbers for your home.
With solid decking and underlayment it is usually comparable to other roofs.
No. It does not attract lightning more than other materials, and it is noncombustible.
Comparison guideRoofing Materials ComparedAsphalt shingles, metal, slate, synthetic slate, cedar shake, clay and concrete tile and flat roof membranes compared by…Learn more 
Comparison guideRepair vs ReplacementWhen a roof can be repaired, when sections should be replaced and when a full replacement is the…Learn more 
Comparison guideSiding Materials ComparedVinyl, fiber cement, engineered wood and natural wood siding compared by look, durability, care and installation needs.Learn more 
Comparison guideGutter Types ComparedK-style, half-round and box gutters in aluminum, steel and copper compared by capacity, look, durability and care.Learn more Call us and describe your roof, siding or gutters. We will look at your property, talk through options and give you a clear written estimate.
